The Scheele Preserve is a secluded tract of land on the east side of the island that features a short half-mile hiking trail. The entrance to the trail is located on the east side of Monagan Road, just north of the intersection with Hamilton Road. The preserve is less than half a mile from the main entrance to the East Quarry trails. The trail passes through open meadow, groves of low-growing trees, and thickets of tall grass before arriving at a quiet slice of shell beach.